Rev. Dr. Roger L. Shinn, Theologian, Dies at 96
Published: June 2, 2013
The Rev. Dr. Roger L. Shinn, an educator, administrator and author who championed the ecumenical movement and social activism in Protestant churches as their growth peaked in the 1950s and ’60s, died on May 13 at his home in Southbury, Conn. He was 96.
The New York Times
His family announced his death.
Perhaps Dr. Shinn’s signal moment came after the 1957 merger of two mainstream denominations, the Evangelical and Reformed Church and the Congregational Christian Churches, to form the United Church of Christ. He was the principal author of the statement of faith for the denomination, which is still used in words close to his original. (References to God as a male, for example, have been made gender-neutral.)
Dr. Shinn’s personal journey included fighting in the Battle of the Bulge as an infantryman in World War II and winning a Silver Star for valor. He later counseled conscientious objectors during the Vietnam War.
At Union Theological Seminary in New York, Dr. Shinn studied with giants of 20th-century religious thought — Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Reinhold Niebuhr and Paul Tillich — and was himself later the Reinhold Niebuhr professor of social ethics at Union.
He helped shape the flurry of theological debate that followed World War II, arguing for a sharper sense of ethical and social responsibility on the part of moderate Protestant churches (Methodists, Presbyterians, Congregationalists, Episcopalians and kindred denominations) whose membership peaked in the early 1960s at 31 million.
The discussion reflected a gnawing need to make sense of a postwar world so emptied of certainties that many clergy members felt compelled to offer evidence on why God still lived.
Dr. Shinn’s answer to the “Is God dead?” question was that old ideas of God died repeatedly. “But it is not God who is changing,” he said in a 1966 interview with The Boston Globe, “only our own concepts and broadening cosmic horizons.”
Gary Dorrien, the current Reinhold ethics professor at Union, said in an interview that Dr. Shinn’s 15 books asked more questions than they answered, but that those questions were indisputably large: “What’s going on? How should we think about it? How do we include voices in this conversation that have been excluded previously?”
Dr. Shinn’s books discussed, among other topics, death, war, the nature of history and the usefulness of existentialism to both believers and nonbelievers.
The statement of faith for the United Church of Christ called on believers to “resist the powers of evil,” an implicit endorsement of the social activism that became a hallmark of the new church and much of mainline Protestantism. Their causes included fighting for civil rights, protesting the spread of nuclear weapons and working to alleviate hunger.
J. Martin Bailey, former editor of The United Church Herald, said in an interview that the document echoed Bonhoeffer’s call for believers to find God in their own lives. Dr. Shinn wrote that those who trust in God are promised “courage in the struggle for justice and peace” and eternal life.
Roger Lincoln Shinn was born in Germantown, Ohio, on Jan. 6, 1917. He graduated from Heidelberg College (now University) in Tiffin, Ohio, in 1938, and from Union in 1941. As managing editor of a student journal, he persuaded Albert Einstein to write an article on science and religion.
In June 1941 he wrote a full-page essay for The New York Journal-American, “Why I Entered the Ministry in a World Gone Mad,” in which he said, “A young man stepping out with a Bible in his hand and some ideals in his head looks like a pretty futile fellow.”
The essay was accompanied by photographs of the destruction wreaked on England by German bombs. Dr. Shinn pluckily promised that he and other newly minted clergy members would thrive on their faith and senses of humor. He went off to war.
He was ordained in 1946 and taught as an instructor at Union for two years before becoming a professor at Heidelberg, then at Vanderbilt University in Nashville. He returned to Union in 1960 as a professor. He was dean of instruction from 1963 to 1970, and from 1974 to 1975 he was acting president after Bishop J. Brooke Mosley was forced out. Dr. Donald W. Shriver Jr. succeeded him.
Dr. Shinn also held temporary teaching posts at New York University, the Jewish Theological Seminary of America and the United States Military Academy at West Point. He served terms as president of the American Theological Society and the Society of Christian Ethics.
Dr. Shinn is survived by his wife of 69 years, the former Katharine Cole; two daughters, Carol Wheeler and Marybeth Shinn; a sister, Ruth Shinn; four grandchildren; and four great-grandchildren.
Over the years, Dr. Shinn was known for expressing provocative views in speeches and interviews. He said the Black Death of 14th-century Europe was, in a way, kinder than the AIDS epidemic because nobody blamed the plague’s victims. Questioning human cloning, he characterized the possibility as fundamentally conservative because, he said, it could only replicate what is, not create a new, unexpected being.
He could also be intellectually playful, as he was at a 1966 conference with poets and playwrights on the concept of absurdity. He observed that the playwright Eugène Ionesco, a leading light in the Theater of the Absurd, was “basically a moralist” in his depiction of the insignificance of existence.
“Theology has always had a vested interest in foolishness,” Dr. Shinn said.